Monday, April 30, 2012

Amazing story of captured Bible's return to soldier from Maine -- 60 years later

The following is among my favorite stories in the nearly three-year existence of the Civil War Picket.

On April 21, 2012, Robert Clayton of Islesboro, Maine, returned a Confederate battle flag to Fort McAllister, Ga., 147 years after its capture by his great-grandfather, Capt. W.Z. Clayton. There's a side story that may be even more incredible.

Robert Clayton has in his possession the Bible that belonged to W.Z. Clayton. The Union soldier lost the Bible at a battle and it went into the hands of a Confederate. A Union officer "recaptured" it two years later in fighting near Atlanta. After a lot of twists and turns, the Bible got back to W.Z. Clayton in late 1923 or early 1924 -- 62 years after he had last seen it. Robert Clayton provided most of the following information, and I've done as much additional research as I practically can at this moment. I'd love to be able to fill in the gaps:




William Zoron Clayton, a native of Freeman, Maine, was 25 when the Civil War began. He joined the 1st Minnesota Light Artillery. His wife, Elizabeth "Lizzie" Rice Clayton, gave him this small Bible. She inscribed (above, click to enlarge) the first verse of a popular 1830s song, "Sweet Memories of Thee." The words are: "When soft stars are peeping, Through the pure azure sky, And southern gales sweeping, Their warm breathings by -- Like sweet music pealing Far o'er the blue sea, there comes o'er me stealing Sweet memories of thee."

Another inscription in the Bible (click to read) tells the bearer to keep it close. The penmanship does not appear to be Elizabeth's. At the time, the verse was commonly written in Bibles.

W.Z. Clayton, while a sergeant, wrote the following message to whomever might come in possession of his Bible. (click below to enlarge) The remainder of the message will be presented later in this post.



The 1st Minnesota Light Artillery saw its first significant action of the Civil War at Shiloh on April 6, 1862. Clayton was wounded in the great clash at the Hornet's Nest. It's not clear how he lost custody of the Bible. Perhaps the sergeant dropped it or the Rebel found it in the battery's camp, forward of the Peach Orchard. Clayton's unit barely escaped capture that day.

The Bible was then signed by L. Herndon, Co. I, 1st Regiment Mississippi Cavalry. Sgt. Lucien (possibly) Lucius Herndon was a member of the Pontotoc Dragoons. (Click photo below to enlarge)

On April 6, at Shiloh, the 1st Mississippi Calvary advanced on the left flank of Cheatham's Division. One of their officers captured a different Union battery that was poised to retreat to the Tennessee River at Pittsburg Landing. The Mississippi unit later fought in Louisiana, Alabama, middle Tennessee and Georgia.

Sadly, Clayton's wife, Lizzie, died on May 10, 1864, according to ancestry.com. W.Z. Clayton at that time was in North Georgia taking part in the Atlanta Campaign, serving with 1st Minnesota Light Artillery.

I do not know what became of Herndon and whether he or the 1st Mississippi Cavalry were at the Battle of Jonesboro, a Union victory south of Atlanta Aug. 31-Sept 1, 1864. But I think it's likely they did.

At Jonesboro, the Bible came into possession of 1st. Lt. Obed Sherwin of the 47th Ohio Volunteery Infantry (click photo to enlarge, who added his name. Sherwin, of Jefferson Township, Ohio, was wounded some time during the war by a round that killed another soldier.

The 47th OVI saw early service in Virginia. The regiment transferred west and joined the 15th Corps in time for the 1863 Vicksburg operation. Later in the fall, the Buckeyes joined the Chattanooga-Ringgold campaign and took part in Georgia operations. Sherwin mustered out in January 1865.

Above Sherwin's notation is the balance of W.Z. Clayton's note to whomever might find his New Testament. It asks it be returned to his father, Bartholomew, in Freeman, Maine. It also notes W.Z.'s membership in a masonic lodge.

From here, the story of the recaptured Bible becomes murky, with few details.

Robert Clayton said the Bible eventually to a Capt. Thomas, who moved to Texas and held the Bible for about 40 years. Mrs. Thomas gave it to a J.A. Creath in Gurdon, Ark., in December 1923 (click photo to enlarge). Someone saw the inscription that indicated W.Z. Clayton was a Mason, and through that fraternal order, was able to locate the former Union officer and send the Bible to him.

After the war, Clayton married Laurette E. Knowles and they had six children. He passed away in October 1929 in Bangor, Maine, at 94.

Tussle 2: Updates on medals, prison key

Ohio cousins feuding over ownership of Civil War artifacts plan to ask whether the items could be displayed at a Veterans Affairs clinic being built near Toledo. • Article

Saturday, April 28, 2012

Tennessee tussle over Farragut marker

Even as Tennessee and county officials prepare to dedicate a Civil War trail marker to Admiral David Glasgow Farragut this weekend, the fate of the stone monument marking the birthplace of the first admiral of the U.S. Navy remains uncertain. • Article

Friday, April 27, 2012

Will Sultana rise from the ashes to earn a more prominent place in U.S. memory?

• Last of a series

What's left of the SS Sultana is in loam, 35 feet beneath an Arkansas soybean field. The mighty Mississippi River changed course since the steamboat exploded and caught fire on April 27, 1865, leaving the ashes to slowly settle and be farmed over.

“We know it’s there. It also is hallowed ground," said Louis Intres, adjunct history professor at Arkansas State University.

While Intres expects the charred timbers to stay put, he and a small band of scholars, authors and descendants have campaigned to keep alive the memory of the largest U.S. maritime disaster, which claimed about 1,800 lives. Most of the victims were freed Union prisoners headed north.

But it hasn't been easy.

Few Americans know about the Sultana, and there are concerns that future citizens won't wade deeply into history.

“Our younger generation is just not as fascinated by stories of the Civil War as we are," said Pam Newhouse of the Association of Sultana Descendants and Friends (ASDF). "My best hope is for people to talk about it. In that way, the story will never die.”

That was the mission of the Sultana Association, an organization founded in Ohio by survivors in 1885. Veterans shared their first-hand accounts and held reunions.

Survivors fought, to no avail, for congressional support for a national monument. Instead, communities home to the Union soldiers who were being transported after the war's end erected monuments. East Tennessee survivors put up one in Knoxville in 1916 (photo).

Pleasant Keeble (below) of Knoxville, survived the Sultana; his brother, John, did not. The last survivors' meeting in his city was held in April 1930, with only Keeble, 84, in attendance. The former private of Company H, 3rd Tennessee Calvary, died the following year.

Today, the ASDF is pinning its hopes for a lasting memorial on a museum, perhaps in Marion, Ark., a few miles north of Memphis, Tenn.

The overcrowded steamboat sank early in the morning near Marion. In the end, no one was formally held accountable for putting too many men on the Sultana and sailing despite documented concerns about the safety of one of the boat's boilers. Hundreds of men died only a day and a half from a prisoner exchange and freedom.

The disaster received scant headlines.

America was weary of the Civil War and was still mourning President Abraham Lincoln, assassinated fewer than three weeks before.

Confederate Gen. Joseph E. Johnston had just surrendered his army in North Carolina.

The South, focused on its own devastation, wasn't particularly sympathetic about enemy soldiers perishing, said Jerry Potter, a Memphis lawyer who has written extensively about the topic.

“I was giving a talk one time, and a man made a comment that they were just Yankees, too bad more of them didn’t die," Potter told the Picket. "I just lost it. A few people felt that way, but few people knew about the Sultana.”

• Excerpts from Sultana victim's journal

The city of Marion and the chamber of commerce last month sponsored an exhibit on the Sultana, featuring a few items from the ship, reunion pins, photos and accounts of the disaster.

Intres, 63, a retired banker, expects Arkansas State to house the Sultana's permanent archives. Marion would like to restore an old bank building and use is at a first location for a steamboat museum.

"Of course, we would likely use the Sultana as the central theme, but it should celebrate the great era of steamboats from about 1820 to the early 20th century," he said. As a child, Intres learned about rivers from a retired steamboat pilot.

But it will take about 10 years and a lot of money to make that happen. "It is a wonderful dream right now," said Intres.

• (Read about alligator box made by survivor)

Intres and others say Marion and Memphis could benefit from increased heritage tourism. But governments aren't in a spending mode these days.

“There’s no state funding or local funding. It’s up to societies and communities," said Jimmy Ogle, a tour guide and community engagement manager for the Riverfront Development Corp. in Memphis. “It was just perceived as a small steamboat disaster in the South.”

“We’re trying to build that interest," said Ogle, who has led tours to the Sultana site. "The Civil War kind of skipped over Memphis.”

The city fell to Federal forces in 1862 and became a logistics and hospital center. “Sherman planned the March from the Sea here. There is no signature thing like a battlefield, such as Shiloh,” he said.

Memphis could serve as a hub to see additional Civil War sites, including Shiloh, Fort Donelson and Fort Pillow, according to Ogle. The Mississippi River Museum on Mud Island in Memphis has several galleries about the war.

Some people are afraid to discuss slavery and revisionism, according to Ogle. “All we’re trying to do is recognize history is an objective and historical perspective.”

Potter said he did not understand the magnitude of the Sultana disaster until he got into his research.

“I would love to see the national papers and networks pick up on the story again," he said. "There are still a lot of people who have ancestors on the boat who know nothing about it.”

Stories of those who died and survived are gripping.

In "The Sultana Tragedy: America's Greatest Maritime Disaster," Potter writers about Pleasant and John Keeble being on separate decks. Pleasant was pushed downstairs by a stampede but made it back on deck, unable to find John. (Photo: Sultana survivors in Knoxville, 1920. Keeble is believed to be on the far left.)

Pleasant Keeble jumped into the river and use a portion of a wheelhouse to get away. Gene Salecker, in his book "Disaster on the Mississippi, said an African-American man on the bank extended a pole to Keeble, pulling him to safety.

Pvt. James Collins, also of the 3rd Tennessee Cavalry, wrote in his memoris about his excitement on being on the Sultana, his wartime hardships over.

Suddenly, the ship trembled as the boilers exploded.

"Men lay everywhere scalded to death by the hot, hissing steam . . . and everywhere on the ill-fated boat death was visible in countless horrible and shocking forms," he wrote.

Badly burned by the cinders, Collins made his escape.

• (Read article about scale model of Sultana)

Local residents, including a freed slaves, helped the passengers, who found themselves swimming for shore, or thrashing about in the chilly Mississippi.

“There were some amazing stories of heroism," said Intres. About 700 people were saved, with 200 dying for their wounds. Bodies were recovered for the next several months.

“Those who had survived so much felt like a calling," said Intres. "A great many went on to do wonderful things with their lives.”

Salecker has a large collection of Sultana memorabilia, including a wooden comb (right) and a box made by a survivor. He loaned a portion of it to the Marion exhibit and would like to see it housed in a permanent museum.

A fitting time would be by April 2015, the 150th anniversary of the sinking.

“I have a funny feeling the Sultana will be pushed aside much like it was in 1865. There will be attention to the Lincoln assassination, hunt for Booth and it will be a side note, said Salecker.

The ASDF is holding its 25th annual reunion today and Saturday in Cincinnati, Ohio.

Norman Shaw, an active member, said he is worried about the organization recruiting enough new members.

“We have got a lot done in spreading the word," said Shaw, of Knoxville. “Even those who died had a story to tell. They didn’t get to finish their story.”

Intres, the historian, said most museums are at least 30 years old. But, he said, America would lose much by forgetting its past.

“How valuable do you think your past is? How valuable is your heritage?" he asked. "You can’t go out and remake history."

• Association of Sultana Descendants and Friends

Photos of Pvt. Pleasant Keeble and Knoxville monument, courtesy of Norman Shaw; photo of 1920 Knoxville reunion, Thompson Photograph Collection, McClung Historical Collection; photo of Sultana, Library of Congress; photo of Sultana tour, courtesy of Jimmy Ogle; photo of exhibit, Marion, Ark., Chamber of Commerce.

Thursday, April 26, 2012

This soldier actually was a sailor

Almost 150 years after George Adams Harriman of Orland, Maine, enlisted to fight the Confederacy, descendants have confirmed which military service he joined. They have marked his grave with a memorial stone that honors his service. • Article