Friday, November 20, 2026

Brandon Bies handled remains of three unknown Union soldiers buried in a Second Manassas limb pit. He was at Arlington this month for a final goodbye. Their stories still provide lessons today, the NPS veteran says

Bies at Manassas dig in 2015 (Kate D. Sherwood/Smithsonian Institution) and in November 2026 (Picket photo)
Brandon Bies did not expect the twinge of emotion that came upon him after this month’s funeral at Arlington National Cemetery for a young New York soldier who died 164 years ago at Second Manassas.

Army officials had placed the metal casket, chairs and tent about 100 feet away from where the teen was to be interred next to two other Union soldiers who died at the same field hospital.

Bies, a National Park Service archaeologist and park manager, was very familiar with all three. He had gently handled their skeletal remains following their discovery during a utility project at Manassas National Battlefield Park.

“I actually got misty-eyed when I walked over after the funeral, put my hand on the grave stone, and knew this soldier was going to be buried directly next to them. That was in the same alignment they were in the ground,” Bies said in a recent phone call. “That connection … was emotional for me.”

The Old Guard carries remains of a Union soldier to his funeral on Nov. 4 (Civil War Picket photo)
The discovery of the unknown soldiers -- two in 2015 and the third in 2024 -- was a surprise. They had been placed in a shallow grave called a surgeon’s limb pit. With them were amputated limbs.

Bone fragments had turned up in 2014 during water line maintenance at Manassas National Battlefield Park. National Park Service archaeologists, Bies among them, were called in to conduct what became the first excavation of a battlefield surgeon’s burial pit. He also participated in a second dig at the site nearly a decade later.

“They were shockingly similar, because in both cases we did not expect to find complete sets of remains,” said Bies.

In total, three sets of remains and 16 amputated limbs were located. Because of poor soil conditions, officials decided to remove them; the first two bodies were laid to rest with full military honors at Arlington in 2018.

I saw Bies (pronounced byes) at the Nov. 4 funeral and it prompted me to ask for a conversation. Bies has worn many hats in his NPS career, among them superintendent at Manassas (2017-2021) and a stint at Arlington House, not far from where soldiers rest in Section 81.


Bies, currently deputy superintendent at Acadia National Park in Maine, said nods to the unknown fallen are all around Arlington, including the Tomb of the Civil War Unknowns (above), near Arlington House. Some 2,111 soldiers were gathered after the Civil War, 1,800 of them from Bull Run (Manassas) alone. (U.S. Army photo)

Bies said the story of these three soldiers amplifies the importance of land preservation and interpretation – and keeping the stories of sacrifice alive.

“This is the ultimate example of why we call these battlefields hallowed ground,” he said. “There undoubtedly still are soldier remains left on those battlefields.”

Two large armies again converged at Manassas

Currier and Ives dramatized depiction of the fight at Second Manassas (Library of Congress)
During his time at the park, Bies wanted to bring more attention to Second Manassas, which occurred in late August 1862 (the first battle was in July 1861). "So many people do not understand the second battle was four times the size of the first battle.”

Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee, after stalling a Federal advance on Richmond, Va., moved troops north to attack a large army that had been shielding Washington, D.C.

This caused near-panic in the nation’s capital.

“They were terrified and they were convinced the Confederate army was going to march on Washington,” said Bies.

The smashing Confederate victory at Second Manassas laid the groundwork for the invasion of Maryland and the Battle of Antietam, just a few weeks later.

But it came at a huge cost.

Between them, the Northern and Southern armies suffered more than 21,000 casualties. Among them were the three Union soldiers and those who lost arms and legs that were buried near them in the limb pit. (At right, an Enfield bullet is lodged in one of the soldier's femur,  Kate D. Sherwood / Smithsonian Institution)

The field hospital was established at the John Dogan farm, not far from the Deep Cut section of the battlefield. The property was known as Rosefield at the time.

Union soldiers occupied this property on August 29, 1862, first using it as an artillery placement site, and later as a field hospital after surgeons “took control of the house” for the remainder of the three-day battle, the NPS said.

Under horrifying circumstances, Union surgeons covered up to their elbows in blood worked feverishly to save lives at a makeshift field hospital on the Second Manassas battlefield.

The ground had been won by the Confederates in August 1862, but the surgeons had been granted permission to treat the Federal wounded, many of whom had been without care, food and water for days following their futile assaults.

These poor men's wounds were unsurvivable

Hard choices on who to treat had to be made, according to a study written after the 2015 excavation and co-authored by Bies. “They rendered aid as they were able until surgeons became uncertain whether operations could be tolerated by men already so weakened from their ordeal,” the paper says.

In December 2020, Bies told members of the Rappahannock Valley Civil War Round Table the amputated limbs showed clean saw marks, indicating the surgeons were skilled.

Bies told me surgeon Benjamin Howard (left) and his colleagues used chloroform or other products during amputations and surgery at Manassas. “After an amputation, there were no pain killers.”

The three soldiers had mortal wounds when they were carried to the field hospital. One may have been with the 12th or 17th New York, which fought at Deep Cut

An Enfield bullet had ripped into the upper femur of so-called Soldier 1. Soldier 2 suffered several buck and ball wounds. Blood loss and shock made their wounds unsurvivable. “The surgeon likely made the very difficult decision” not to operate, said Bies.

And then there is the Soldier 3, a boy between 16 years and 19 years old who stood just over 5 feet tall. He suffered a wound to the neck, likely damaging the spinal column. “He may have been paralyzed at this point.” That likely affected his breathing.

When archaeologists returned to the limb pit area in 2024, they came across Soldier 3. With him were six brass New York State Excelsior coat buttons (NPS photo, right) and seven brass cuff buttons, evidence he work a New York jacket.

Under his leg was a rubber pocket comb. An associated NPS document says the comb was mass-produced, machine made and undecorated. (The item was placed in the casket before the Nov. 4 burial at Arlington.

The buttons and a metal clothing hook remain with the NPS.

Archaeologists felt they had to relocate remains

I can only imagine the chaos and carnage at the temporary field hospital, which operated under brutal conditions in the summer heat.

The bodies and amputated limbs were buried just 10 inches deep. “It would not be unreasonable to bury and cover with dirt as quickly as possible,” said Bies.

Soldier 1 and Soldier 2 were placed next to each other, arm over arm. 

The boy may have been placed in an adjacent second hole, just a few feet away, said Bies, indicating they may have been buried at different times. The field hospital operated for several days in early September 1862. (At left, Bies examines remains with scientist Kari Bruwelheide in 2018. Photo: Kate D. Sherwood, Smithsonian Institution)

The National Park Service generally does not remove remains from a battlefield. But that had to be waived with the Manassas finds.

“I can tell you the soil conditions were extremely poor. It was some of the poorest preservation of any site I have ever seen,” said Bies, adding the shallow depth increased exposure to harmful frost and moisture. “You are exposed to a tremendous amount of change. And this is not good for preservation.”

The Army, before the Arlington burials, did not ask for DNA samples to be taken and none were. An updated NPS page about the surgeon’s pit explains the rationale.

“The NPS will conduct stable isotope analysis and historical research on the third soldier’s remains and the amputated limbs (as it did for the 2015 finds) that, we hope, will help us formally identify these individuals,” the agency said.

Officials have not disclosed the precise location of the Manassas limb pit.

How story of the second battle is told at park

It’s a fair bet to say most people who drive to Manassas National Battlefield Park are most drawn to the story of the first battle, given the legends about picnicking civilians fleeing back to Washington, along with the boys in blue.

And then there is the monument to Brig. Gen. Thomas Jonathan “Stonewall” Jackson, who earned his famous nickname that day in 1861.


There are many markers on the field related to Second Manassas, but none are on Henry Hill or Matthews Hill, associated with the first fight. The park museum does have a small exhibit (above) about treatment of the wounded, said curator Jim Burgess. 

Four other exhibits tell parts of the Second Manassas story, and there are some accompanying artifacts.

Jackson’s troops and Brig. Gen. John Gibbon’s forces battled near the Brawner Farmhouse (right) to open the second battle. Archaeologists digging around the standing house have found military objects and artifacts left by the people who lived on the farm.

The house is open to visitors only on weekends during the summer and that is dependent on available volunteers. The grounds are open sunrise to sunet.

Burgess said the boy soldier’s buttons may go on temporary exhibit one day at the park.

In 2018. Bies went out to the battlefield with an NPR reporter. "Over 100,000 soldiers had trampled, shot, exploded, eaten, burned everything. And so the water was tainted, every single house (and) barn was occupied by wounded soldiers, and these surgeons had very little to work with," he told NPR.

Balancing feelings of excitement and solemnity

Bies told the Rappahannock Valley Civil War Round Table the discovery of the remains was one of the most exciting of his NPS career.


He told me the Nov. 4 Arlington funeral (Picket video, above) was the closing of one chapter, but the need to preserve and tell stories of those who served continues.

“This is a story that is going to be told” at Manassas, whether at the visitor center or a wayside marker. (Bies advised he does not speak in an official capacity for the site, given he left five years ago for new assignments.)

Bies spoke of his different perspectives -- as an archaeologist and a park manager.

Bies (hands in pocket) with NPS staffers at the Nov. 4 funeral at Arlington (Picket photo)
“It is easy as a military archaeologist to get very excited about the discovery and the artifacts we found.” Such projects are fun and rewarding, he added.

“(But) it is incredibly humbling to be holding in your hands the projectiles that actually killed those soldiers. I can tell you the gun and caliber, the indentations.”

“These three soldiers suffered horrible deaths that were painful and not immediate. Families never found out what happened to them. This is the very emotional part of this. You are balancing excitement and (the) honor to tell these soldiers’ stories.”

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Yes, the new Sultana Disaster Museum shows a paddlewheel housing with simulated human waste. It depicts some of the awful conditions on overloaded steamboat

Exhibit designers decided to get real in showing realities of the Sultana's last journey (Civil War Picket)
As I drove back Sunday to metro Atlanta from Marion, Ark. -- where the Sultana Disaster Museum opened to the public the day before -- I was formulating what I thought would be a light, quick-and-easy feature with plenty of scatological humor.

I had noticed the museum’s mockup of one of the steamboat’s paddlewheel housings featured streaks of brown of running downward.

Could that be a representation of human excrement?

Well, yes, it was. A photograph (left, Library of Congress) of the ill-fated and overcrowded Sultana -- taken in Helena, Ark., a day before it exploded and caught fire on April 27, 1864 – showed the streaks, just below loitering soldiers.

For all the posts I have written about the disaster, I never had noticed or heard about that.

As I said, I thought at first this could be a “fun” item with lots of bad puns. But as I further studied the conditions these poor 2,000 souls dealt with, the visual wasn’t really all that funny at all. Especially considering nearly 1,200 passengers and crew died

Hundreds of soldiers, recently released from Andersonville and Cahaba prisons, were packed onto a vessel not intended to carry more than 300-400 passengers.

And they were desperately staying alive to get home to families that dearly missed them.

Mockup of promenade deck and paddlewheel (far left) are in the Sultana museum (Civil War Picket)
Jeff Kollath, executive director of the museum, told me the exhibit’s designer had heard about the excrement and insisted it be shown. “I saw this and thought, ‘That’s extreme,’” Kollath told me.

For whatever it’s worth, I didn’t hear any patrons at the grand opening talk about that feature, though I am guessing some did.

Noted Sultana expert and author Gene Salecker said the Sultana’s two restrooms for cabin passengers were located behind the paddlewheel boxes on the second deck. (The boat’s 38 staterooms each had a chamber pot and there may have been some on the main deck, too.)

“When you went to the restroom, the poop or urine dropped down directly into the churned-up water that was directly behind the paddlewheels,” Salecker said.

Clearly, there were more passengers than latrine capacity. And many of the weakened soldiers were likely suffering from diarrhea and/or dysentery.

Gene Salecker uses this slide in his presentations on the boat; click to enlarge (Courtesy GS)
“I am not sure how many of the men had dysentery. That's a pretty disabling ailment and, remember, you had to be in pretty good shape to walk aboard the Sultana,” said Salecker. “Still, we know that there were sixteen sick men that were bedded down directly in front of the main saloon, right above the warm boilers.” At least one of the boilers failed, leading to the disaster.

“On the crowded Sultana, it would have been almost impossible to go to the second deck and get in line to use the restroom, especially if you were suffering from dysentery or diarrhea,” Salecker said. “Instead, they used one of the fire buckets and then tossed the waste over the side of the paddlewheel housing. You didn't want to throw it from anywhere else because it could blow back into where the people were.”

The photograph of the Sultana shows black holes on top of the paddlewheel box. Soldiers likely emptied themselves through those holes.


When the fire broke out in the middle of the night, futile efforts to subdue it were almost certainly hampered by the use of fire buckets for excrement. (Photo above, courtesy Gene Salecker)

Fire buckets had round bottoms and were held in racks, usually full of water. When the explosion occurred and people such as Maj. William H. Fidler and his aide, Capt. James M. McCown, both 6tth Kentucky Cavalry, went to look for the fire buckets, the racks were empty.

“The small fire was soon out of control. The actions of the men in using the buckets for excrement aided their own demise,” said Salecker.

The museum includes searchable blueprints that the author and researcher drew in 1978. They show the locations of the restrooms. His sources included Leonard V. Huber, an early writer on steamboats; plans in the book “Steamboats on the Mississippi”; and plans of the steamboat Buckeye State. (At left, location of restrooms, courtesy Gene Salecker)

He went through the Cincinnati newspapers of January and February 1863 to get the proper dimensions for the paddlewheels, hull length and width during construction.

It wasn’t just humans relieving themselves while on the Sultana, which left Vicksburg, Ms., days earlier and was headed for Cairo, Ill.

About 100 government mules and horses and three or four milk cows were onboard. The latter were in the stern area.

As recounted in survivor Chester Berry’s book, “Loss of the Sultana and Reminiscences of Survivors,” Cpl. Jesse Martin, Company D, 35th Indiana Infantry, recalled sleeping the the cargo area. The explosion blew him across the deck, and he awakened on his knees besides a cow, “as though I had got there to milk her,” Martin said.

Clock to enlarge for detailed look at the Sultana, passengers in April 1865 (Library of Congress)

Monday, November 16, 2026

With ribbon-cutting, the story of the Sultana disaster steams ahead. Search our Facebook page for photographs, videos and wonderful stories from descendants

I am back home after four days in Marion, Ark., for events related to the grand opening of new and improved Sultana Disaster Museum. The weather was sunny and so were the dispositions of most everyone I met.

Descendants of the soldiers who died or survived the largest maritime disaster in U.S. history were wowed by the static and interactive exhibits. Some were brought to tears. Officials stressed the work is not done; they expect tweaks and additions to be made in the years ahead to the $11 million facility.

The town across from Memphis, Tenn., hopes the museum will provide a revenue boost, given Hino Motors -- its largest employer -- is closing its manufacturing plant there next year.

I posted numerous photographs and vignettes on my Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/civilwarpicket

I expect a couple more Sultana posts here in the near future. I recommend you stop by Marion if you are in the Memphis area or driving through northeast Arkansas. You’ll learn something about this overlooked chapter of the Civil War, and might leave with a tear in your eyes.

Monday, November 9, 2026

Stars of the Sultana: Tennessee cavalryman 'Plez' Keeble and a mule competed for a piece of the boat's wreckage. Keeble won out and went on to live a long life. His brother, also on the Sultana, was not as fortunate

Pvt. Pleasant Keeble (left) survived the Sultana disaster; his brother John Keeble (right) did not
Submitted by Norman Shaw

Ahead of the Nov. 14 grand opening of the new Sultana Disaster Museum in Marion, Ark., the Civil War Picket asked experts and descendants for submissions about the people involved in the story – the soldiers, the survivors, the heroes and the scoundrels. The overloaded steamboat exploded and caught fire in the Mississippi River on April 27, 1865. About 1,200 people perished, many of them released Federal POWs heading home at the end of the war. Norman Shaw, a Knoxville, Tenn., resident and founder of the Sultana Association of Descendants and Friends, submitted the following about Pleasant Keeble. (Part 1 of the series is here, Part 2 is here and Part 3 is here)

Pleasant (Plez) Keeble, 17, must have been excited when he learned Maj. Gen. Ambrose Burnside's Union army had arrived in Knoxville, Tenn., on September 3, 1863, after a grueling march over the rugged Appalachian Mountains from Kentucky. 

This gave Plez the opportunity to join the 3rd Tennessee Cavalry on February 16, 1864, to serve with his older brother, John, who enlisted in the regiment early in the war, on August 10, 1862, and assigned to Company A, the initial company formed. Although placed in Company H, the younger Keeble was probably content to know he would be near his big brother for the remainder of the war.

Neither soldier could imagine the terrible events that awaited them.

First, the remnants of the 3rd Tennessee Cavalry would be sent to the small Rebel prison at Cahaba, Ala., a converted cotton warehouse with little or no roof, following their capture almost en masse by Confederate Maj. Gen. Nathan Bedford Forrest in September 1864. (The Federal troopers had been positioned in forts at  Athens, Ala., and Sulphur Branch Trestle, seven miles north of Athens on the railroad line.)

Former POW Jesse Hawes' drawing of Cahaba prison in Alabama
Having survived several months of captivity at the Confederate pen at Cahaba, including standing in knee-deep water for three days caused by the flooded Alabama River flowing nearby, the Union survivors were transported in March 1865 to a recovery camp at Camp Fisk, located four miles east of Vicksburg, to regain their strength for a steamboat journey to Cairo, Ill. From here, they would be transported by train to Columbus, Ohio, to be mustered out of the army.

Unfortunately, the Keeble brothers, along with their comrades in the 3rd Tennessee Cavalry, were loaded April 24, 1865, onto the ill-fated steamer Sultana, at Vicksburg, along with other former POWs from several Midwestern states, totaling almost 2,000 men.

Dedication of Sultana monument near Knoxville in July 4, 1916 (courtesy of Norman Shaw)
The overcrowded Sultana would unexpectedly explode on the Mississippi River seven miles above Memphis at 2 a.m. on April 27, 1865, killing nearly 1,200 people, including most of the crew, civilians and soldiers, America's worst maritime disaster.

After the explosion, Plez, sleeping on the hurricane deck, frantically tried but failed to locate John on the nearby Texas deck. John likely perished in the explosion after a large section of the deck was torn away in the blast.

The private, a nonswimmer, survived by beating off a mule with a stick while floating on boat wreckage with several others.

No doubt, teenager Pleasant Keeble was traumatized for life after losing his older brother John.

1920 Knoxville survivors reunion; Pleasant Keeble at far left, John H. Simpson
second from right (Knox County Public Library, McClung Historical Collection)
Eventually, Plez returned home to Knoxville to live a normal life by working, marrying and starting a family. He faithfully attended almost every reunion of Tennessee Sultana survivors who met in Knoxville and the surrounding area. They were in the sister organization to the Midwestern survivors. 

Plez was repeatedly elected adjutant and for many years kept the minutes of the yearly meetings in a school composition book.


Time took its toll on the Tennessee survivors, leaving only Pleasant and his good friend, John Simpson, alive to attend the 1929 reunion. 
Plez found himself all alone at the 1930 meeting and by 1931 all from the Knoxville area were gone.

To ensure the memory of the Sultana would never be forgotten, the Knoxville veterans collected enough donations to erect a beautiful marble monument in South Knox County that was dedicated on July 4, 1916, the first one in the country, and without any government assistance.

Only the names of the Tennessee men, whether they lived or died on the Sultana, are etched on all four sides of the stone.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Stars of the Sultana: Her ancestor, Pvt. Daniel Garber of the 102nd Ohio, jumped into the Mississippi River in desperation, though he 'could swim but very little'

Daniel Garber in 1862, with wife Matilda and family in 1890. Carol Lundquist's grandfather David stands at far right
Submitted by Carol Lundquist

Ahead of the Nov. 14 grand opening of the new Sultana Disaster Museum in Marion, Ark., the Civil War Picket asked experts and descendants for submissions about the people involved in the story – the soldiers, the survivors, the heroes and the scoundrels. The overloaded steamboat exploded and caught fire in the Mississippi River on April 27, 1865. About 1,200 people perished, many of them released Federal POWs heading home at the end of the war. Carol Lundquist (left) of Minneapolis submitted the following about her paternal great-grandfather, Pvt. Daniel Garber of the 102nd Ohio Volunteer Infantry. Lundquist and her daughter Kirsten will be in Marion for the museum events. (Part 1 of the series is here, Part 2 is here and Part 4 is here)

Daniel’s Civil War history is not especially notable in itself. He entered service as a private, and left as a private.  He was a wagoner or a teamster, and I haven’t found that Company E saw a lot of front-line action.

I think of Daniel’s experience as emblematic of the many thousands of ordinary men who served and survived the horrors of the war, including the Sultana disaster, came home and somehow resumed their lives.  

Daniel Garber (born in Pennsylvania) was a shoemaker and farmer, from Butler, Ohio.  He enlisted in the 102nd OVI, Company E, in August 1862 at age 34, 10 years older than the average age of enlistees. He left behind his wife Matilda and seven children ranging in ages 12 years down to a 6 month old baby. Daniel served for the duration of the war.

He was captured near Athens, Alabama, by Forrest’s cavalry; the 102nd was guarding the railroad. He survived being imprisoned at Cahaba, and survived the Sultana disaster

Daniel came back after the war, resumed shoemaking and farming, and fathered several more children, including my grandfather, David Scott Garber, in 1872.  

What I find extraordinary in Daniel’s story is simply that of survival. His account of the Sultana disaster is in the Chester Berry book (left). Daniel was on the pilot deck, and waited to jump into the water so as not to collide with all the men already in the water. I grew up hearing of how Daniel had to push men off his shutter or piece of wood so as to save himself.

Daniel says himself that he “could swim but very little.” He floated down the cold, dark, flooded Mississippi River, past the lights of Memphis for four more miles before he was picked up by the boat Pocahontas, 11 miles from the site of the explosion. 

Daniel surely knew that many men who were on the Sultana in the same situation were never rescued and their bodies lost to the river forever.  

Daniel (below) was an invalid for a number of years before his death in 1906. 

Of the 13 men from Company E who were on the Sultana, only three survived: William Yeisley, William Lockhart, and Daniel.  William Lockhart was a close friend of Daniel’s and a pallbearer at his funeral. Yeisley married into the Garber family after the war; he married Nancy Garber, who was a niece of Daniel’s.

In 1996, I met William Lockhart’s daughter-in-law at the Mansfield, Ohio Civil War show, thanks to Gene Salecker. She was quite elderly at the time and died within the next year or two.

It was and still is quite an emotional encounter to meet someone with such close ties to Daniel and the Civil War, through William, although she never knew Daniel.

It only emphasized for me how near we are to the Civil War in time and its lasting effects.