Showing posts with label documentary. Show all posts
Showing posts with label documentary. Show all posts

Friday, February 2, 2018

CSS Georgia: Documentary goes deep into story of the Savannah ironclad that kept its secrets under water for 150 years

Michael Jordan films dive preparation 
Cannon comes up in 1984 (John Roberson)

Over a span of nearly 50 years -- ending in 2017 -- dive flags would occasionally go up on a stretch of river where generations before a hulking Confederate ironclad vessel guarded Savannah, Ga, during the Civil War.

Divers, working in visibility that one likened to chocolate pudding, slipped beneath the surface of the Savannah River and down to the disarticulated remains of the vessel that was scuttled by its Confederate crew in December 1864 when the Yankees arrived at the seaport’s front door.

At first, the divers came to survey and better understand the CSS Georgia, which served as what’s called a floating battery. Later expeditions focused on removal of artifacts so that the channel could be cleared and deepened for ever-larger commercial vessels that regularly ply past tourists on River Street.

“Red diver, into the water when ready,” are the first words uttered in a new documentary about the recovery and history of the CSS Georgia, which earned the derisive nickname “Mud Tub” when its supporters learned it was too underpowered to leave the city and attack Federal ships that had bottled up Savannah’s river entrance.

But the city may have gotten something better. The CSS Georgia became a strong element of its extensive water defenses.

Animation of what CSS Georgia may have looked like (USACE/Michael Jordan)

“Sometimes being a failure is the best way to succeed,” filmmaker Michael Jordan says of the ironclad’s emerging role. “As a floating fort, it was impregnable and kept the federal Navy at bay for a couple years.”

Working on a contract from the Savannah office of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which is in charge of the harbor deepening and the removal of the CSS Georgia, Jordan has produced the hourlong production "From Ironclad to Artifact: The Journey of the CSS Georgia.”

Wreckage has so much to tell

The documentary premieres on February 10 at the Trustees Theater in Savannah, part of the annual Gray’s Reef Film Festival, which benefits a foundation dedicated to preserving the marine sanctuary off the Atlantic coast.

As the title states, the CSS Georgia’s story has indeed been a journey, with triumphs and disappointments along the way. Amazing artifacts and ship components have been pulled up and crews got to see cannon and other items out of the water for the first time in 150 years. But the hull was gone, much of the wood is worm-eaten, some parts are gone and researchers have been unable to find blueprints that give clues to its size and construction. Still, they hope to eventually answer some of the mysteries associated with the ironclad, including its size.

Jordan with one of the recovered guns in 2015

Jordan recently told the Picket that while the CSS Georgia never engaged in battle or a duel with a marauding US Navy ship, it has served a larger purpose for later generations. Rather than being destroyed or put out of commission, it became a time capsule – however damaged by dredges – of a period when resource-pressed Southern communities rushed to build ironclads.

The CSS Georgia was unusual in that its armor consisted of lengths of railroad iron backed by layers of timber, forming a formidable protective shell.

The documentary is rich in history about the vessel, which was built locally after the Ladies’ Gunboat Association raised money across the state. It segues to early attempts at salvaging the iron and other valuable metals and then to efforts over the past half century to bring up large artifacts, including cannon, the protective armor casemate, a propeller, machinery and much more. 

The biggest discoveries and recoveries were in 2015 and 2017, when Navy and contract divers, along with a grapple and clamshell device, scooped up thousands of those artifacts and two large chunks of casemate.

Bringing back the '80s

While the public is likely most familiar with the last two recoveries, I was most intrigued by the documentary’s interviews with and photographs of divers, archaeologists and others toiling during the 1970s and 1980s, when funding did not allow for a full-scale recovery.

(USACE, Michael Jordan)

Jordan spoke with Louis “Lou” Tew, (above) a retired Navy officer who dived on the wreckage in 1969. Later surveys found pronounced deterioration of parts of the ironclad, some due to dredging.

The documentary includes archival images, animation of the boat, filming of recoveries, interviews and small re-enactments of events critical to the CSS Georgia’s history.

Archaeologists and divers worked not far from Old Fort Jackson, another part of the city defenses. The CSS Georgia was anchored and faced downstream, only a couple hundred yards from the fortress.

The late John Roberson of Coastal Heritage Society

Two of the ironclad’s cannons brought up in 1984 are on display outside the walls of the brick fort. One was placed in the moat for a time until it could be moved for conservation. Visitors to the fort heard live audio of the 1984 recovery.

Jordan, a former TV news anchor in Savannah and a filmmaker and author, spent 55 days in the field for the $18,500 project. His travels included the National Civil War Naval Museum in Columbus, Ga., and Texas A&M University, where thousands of artifacts are being treated at its Conservation Research Laboratory. Jordan has a passion for the CSS Georgia, writing a master’s paper about it and producing a small film about a decade ago.

His production will serve as one of the Corps’ components in its educational outreach about the CSS Georgia.

'It was like Christmas'

1979 dive (Jonas Jordan/USACE)
Jordan spent a lot of time on the recovery site in summer 2015, when a US Navy dive team was called in to raise large ship components, scores of artillery rounds and several cannon, two of which were large 9-inch Dahlgren guns.

“I didn’t come home for a month,” said Jordan, who has lived for several years in Knoxville, Tenn. “I was out there every day for days while the Navy divers did the cannonballs and the cannons.”

He said he was fascinated by the Navy divers at work, using muscle, advanced technology and salty language to get the job done. Archaeology students used firehoses to blast piles of river much to look for artifacts, including buckles and other personal belongings. “They were giddy.”

“It was like Christmas for me,” Jordan said of shooting the work that summer.

The CSS Georgia never yielded its treasures easily, as the Navy divers learned ahead of time.

Dredging hits and scars, along with salvage attempts not long after the Civil War, made the wreck site a jumble of rotting wood, chunks of casemate and loose rail and machinery.

Divers could only work a couple of hours a day during “slack time” when the strong current wasn’t too strong to work. And the visibility drops off pretty quickly as one heads to the Savannah River bottom 40 or 50 feet below the surface. One diver told Jordan that they could hear and feel the effect of container ships churning only a 100 or so yards away.

Jordan has pored through Texas A&M, Army Corps and National Archives records to learn more about the CSS Georgia, which was largely forgotten until a dredge hit the vessel in 1968.

Railroad armor on casemate (Picket photo)

Archaeologist Gordon Watts, who has dived and studied the wreck site for decades, told the Picket last year at least seven patterns of interlocking railroad iron were used to make the casemate in 1862.

Where did the ship builders get the railroad iron?

“They were likely to be confiscated,” Watts said – specifically from Northern-owned companies, including a line from Brunswick, Ga., to Jacksonville, Fla. The nephew of US Navy Secretary Gideon Welles came to Savannah after the war to try to recover iron and other material, he said.

Jordan said he delved deeply in the Joseph Welles story, learning details of his winning a federal contract to get the CSS Georgia and CSS Savannah remains out of the shipping channel in the late 1860s.

Welles’ crews pulled up iron, but he and Savannah officials quarreled over how good a job he did. “They complained this Yankee carpetbagger is taking this without moving all the obstructions, which they ironically put in their themselves,” Jordan said.

While research is continuing and there is no yet-discovered written record, it’s very possible Welles dumped much of the CSS Georgia’s remnants back into the river during the dispute, Jordan and others have said.

Big catch, a 32-pounder, during the 1980s (Jonas Jordan/USACE)

Where will boat's story be told?

Of course, the human side of the ironclad’s story is important, too. Duty was difficult and tedious; divers recovered several leg irons used on sailors who got into trouble. The CSS Georgia leaked from above and below. And at least one engine operated all the time to pump out that water, with one scientist saying it could have been 120 degrees inside. It was no pleasure cruise.

Jordan said he hopes viewers of the documentary will “be impressed by what the Corps has done here.” The channel deepening prompted the long-term project and saved a large part of the CSS Georgia. The Corps, he said, worked carefully and with top technology to execute a thorough recovery.

For now, conservation of the artifacts continues at Texas A&M. The casemate and many other pieces of the vessel were reburied in a channel for safekeeping, marking the end of the CSS Georgia’s journey, the documentary shows.

The boat belongs to the US Navy, which has reached out to museums in the South about possible exhibition – if the venues can provide proper climate controls. Talks are ongoing and no deals have been announced.

Jordan said his interest in telling the CSS Georgia’s story, whether in print or video productions, will continue.

“It is such a big story. I couldn’t squeeze it all into a film.”

The Gray’s Reef Film Festival is set for Feb. 9-11 in Savannah. A suggested donation to benefit the Gray’s Reef National Marine Sanctuary Foundation is $8 a day for adults and $5 a day for children, students and members of the military. Showings are at Trustees Theater and the Tybee Post Theater. Jordan’s is set for 7 p.m. February 10 at Trustees Theater, 216 E. Broughton Str. See this website for more information and tickets.

Sunday, March 22, 2015

Sultana disaster: New museum, events, documentary to mark 150th anniversary

Overloaded Sultana awaits its destiny (Library of Congress)

The campaign to keep alive the story of the largest maritime disaster in U.S. history has come to fruition, with the upcoming opening of a Sultana museum, a 150th anniversary weekend in an Arkansas river city and the private screening of a documentary backed by actor Sean Astin, best known for the “Lord of the Rings” film trilogy.

“The Sultana is beginning to receive her acknowledgement as the great tragedy to end the Civil War,” said Louis Intres, an adjunct history instructor at Arkansas State University.

The steamboat, traveling on the Mississippi River, exploded and caught fire early on the morning of April 27, 1865, at war’s end. It claimed about 1,800 lives. Most of the victims were freed Union prisoners headed north, believing they were going home.

The incident received little publicity because Americans were weary of the Civil War and still mourning President Abraham Lincoln, assassinated only two weeks before.

Intres and others expect that anniversary events in Marion, Ark., and nearby Memphis, Tenn., planned for late April will bring folks from around the region and country to check out the museum, hear lectures, attend a wreath-laying ceremony and take a bus tour and a “riverboat cruise into history.”

Gene Salecker with Sultana model (Courtesy of Mark Randall)

On Saturday, April 25, passengers will board a vessel in Memphis, and travel on the Mississippi River to the site of the disaster and the wreckage, which lies beneath a cultivated field on the Arkansas side near Marion. The site is on private property, and the field may be underwater because of flooding this time of year.

“The captain has agreed to take the boat upstream, farther than ordinary, in order to get into the area where the (ship) remains are,” Rosalind O’Neal of the Sultana Historic Preservation Society told the Picket.

The Association of Sultana Descendants and Friends (ASDF) will be holding its annual reunion in Marion from April 23-27. Members who go on the cruise may drop roses into the water as a tribute to relatives who died or survived.

In 2012, the Picket wrote extensively about the Sultana, quoting several people as saying they hoped a temporary exhibit that year in Marion would be a precursor to a lasting memorial.

The first step in a permanent Sultana museum will occur April 9, said O’Neal, one of the organizers of the April 23-25 commemoration in Marion.

Sultana artifacts, memorabilia belonging to Gene Salecker

That’s when members of the Arkansas Historical Association will tour the interim Sultana Disaster Museum, leased at 104 Washington St. near the courthouse.

Among items on display will be memorabilia, a large riverboat model and Sultana artifacts belonging to Gene Salecker, who has written and lectured extensively about the vessel. A wall in the building has a list of known passengers.

“It’s almost like a memorial wall for the people on the Sultana,” said O’Neal.

The historical society, the city and the Marion Chamber of Commerce are planning a second, permanent location for the museum. The city, hoping for the benefits of heritage tourism, last year voted to spend $400,000 for such a facility.

(Interesting, an ancestor of Mayor Frank Fogleman was among residents who came to the aid of badly injured or burned Sultana passengers).

“We are in the beginning stages of planning for a permanent museum, and are close to retaining a firm for architectural and exhibit design services,” Michael Demster, president of the Marion Chamber of Commerce, told the Picket. “We have received some nice seed money, but will need to raise more to get the museum worthy of the Sultana.”

Salecker defies sabotage theories (Mark Randall)

O’Neal said there’s a desire for a small theater and interactive exhibits in the future permanent location.

For now, the community’s focus is on the anniversary weekend. Officials encourage people to register now for key events, because many spots are filled.

They hope about 200 people will sign up for the lectures, museum tour, reception, bus tour of Civil War related sites in Arkansas and Tennessee and the $50 riverboat cruise, which includes a barbecue dinner and lecture by Salecker, entitled “It Was Not Sabotage!”

PBS’ “History Detectives” examined whether the ship’s destruction was the act of Confederate sabotage, faulty machinery or “dangerous conditions.”

The overcrowded steamboat sank near Marion. In the end, no one was formally held accountable for putting too many men on the Sultana and sailing despite documented concerns about the safety of one of the boat's boilers.

Salecker and Jerry Potter have written about a kickback scheme between the vessel's financially-strapped captain, J. Cass Mason, the steamer's captain and master, and an Army quartermaster, Lt. Col. Reuben B. Hatch. According to Potter, the transport fee was $5 for an enlisted man, $10 for an officer. Mason agreed to take the enlisted men for $3; Hatch kept the $2.

Salecker collection includes passenger's comb

The Sultana, with nearly 2,300 people on board, was way above passenger capacity at the time of the explosion. Hundreds of Union soldiers died only a day and a half from a prisoner exchange and freedom.

Local residents, including freed slaves, helped the passengers, who found themselves swimming for shore, or thrashing about in the chilly Mississippi River.

“There were some amazing stories of heroism," said Intres. About 700 people were saved, with 200 dying for their wounds. Bodies were recovered over the next several months.

The South, focused on its own devastation, wasn't particularly sympathetic about enemy soldiers perishing, said Potter, a Memphis lawyer who has written extensively about the topic.

“I was giving a talk one time, and a man made a comment that they were just Yankees, too bad more of them didn’t die," Potter told the Picket in 2012. "I just lost it. A few people felt that way, but few people knew about the Sultana.”

Jimmy Ogle, a tour guide and community engagement manager for the Riverfront Development Corp. in Memphis, that same year said it was up to societies and local communities to build a Sultana museum. “It was just perceived as a small steamboat disaster in the South.” 

That’s appears to be changing. More Americans are learning about the disaster, and Intres believes the 150th anniversary and the new documentary on the disaster will do even more.
Sean Astin and Mark Marshall have created the “Remember the Sultana” through a successful Kickstarter campaign.

Monument in Hillsdale, Mich. (Stephenie Kyser)

A private screening is planned for Monday evening, April 27 (the actual sinking anniversary), at the Paradiso in Memphis.

O’Neal said a Civil War encampment in Marion on April 25 will feature re-enactors, a Civil War medicine wagon and an exhibit on the role of African-Americans during the war. Organizers are bringing in students taking Advanced Placement history.

“If they can feel it, see it, touch it, it makes an impression,” she said.

Norman Shaw, of Knoxville, Tenn., a member of the Association of Sultana Descendants and Friends, said he expects about 100 members to attend their reunion and related events in Marion.

About half may remain for the documentary screening Monday, an event independent of Marion's plans. Shaw is planning a visit to the presumed wreckage site for that Sunday, weather permitting.

The cruise the evening before will be an emotional experience, he predicted, especially with the tossing of roses into the Mississippi River.

“I think it will be very moving. It is very meaningful to our people,” Shaw told the Picket. “One person emailed me this is the closure to the story” of an ancestor who was among the victims.


The Sultana Disaster Museum will be open Thursdays-Saturdays from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., and Sundays from 2 p.m. to 4 p.m. Contact the Chamber of Commerce at 870-739-6041 to arrange a group tour. Admission is free for April. Beginning May 1, the cost is $8 for adults, $5 for children under 12. 

Friday, March 26, 2010

Filmmaker Ken Burns: We must not lose our historical compass

Documentary filmmaker Ken Burns knew one thing when he completed the 1990 epic “The Civil War.”

He had seen enough of war.

Through photographs, diaries and stories, Burns had poignantly documented the bloody conflict that claimed more than 600,000 American lives. Like Civil War soldiers, he and his crew felt they had “seen the elephant.”

People then asked Burns to do a film on World War II.

He resisted doing “The War,” which was released in 2007, for several years.

But two startling truths changed his mind about again taking up the topic.

Some 1,000 U.S. WWII vets were dying a day. And high school graduating seniors thought Americans fought with the Germans against Russia.

“We were losing our soldiers and our historical compass,” Burns said in a talk Thursday afternoon at Georgia State University in Atlanta.

The prolific filmmaker has a large body of television work that helps tell the story of America. Among them are “Baseball,” “Jazz,” “Unforgivable Blackness: The Rise and Fall of Jack Johnson,” and, more recently, “The National Parks: America’s Best idea.”

The New Hampshire resident said his films always ask the same question, "Who are we?" Sharing memories helps us heal from turmoil and war, he said.

Thursday’s speech centered on humanity’s fascination with war. Mankind, Burns says, has the lust for war in its DNA.

Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee may have said it best. “It is well that war is so terrible – lest we should grow too fond of it.”

Burn’s talk was laced with quotations from Abraham Lincoln, his favorite president. As a young lawyer, Lincoln spoke at the Lyceum in Springfield, Ill., delivering a speech that foreshadowed the Civil War.

“As a nation of freemen, we must live through all time, or die by suicide,” Lincoln said.

“The Civil War was the closest we ever came to national suicide,” said Burns, 56. “Paradoxically, in order to become one we divided ourselves in two.”

Burns, who is unafraid of controversy, said he was glad that the ghastly human toll documented in “The Civil War” tempered U.S. enthusiasm for bloodshed when the first Gulf War was launched against Iraq in 1990.

For “The War,” Burns told the story of 50 Americans and four communities.

Insisting “there are no ordinary lives,” Burns said the seven-part series stayed away from celebrity generals.

“If you weren’t on the front line in the war, you aren’t in our film.”

Like Lincoln, Burns worries about divisions within America. Citizens today should be aware of how much they are alike, rather than concentrating on their differences, said the documentary maker, who added that education is the key to preventing bloodshed.

Burns said Americans have a history of seeking unity. He quoted remarks Lincoln gave at his first inaugural address in 1861:

"The mystic chords of memory, stretching from every battlefield and patriot grave to every living heart and hearthstone all over this broad land, will yet swell the chorus of the Union, when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature."