(Courtesy of John Banks' Civil War blog) |
The cost of Gordon’s scheme is detailed in federal court documents filed before he was sentenced Tuesday in US District Court in Connecticut to five years’ probation and restitution.
The government had argued a sentence of 12 to 18 months in
prison followed by supervised release would be within guidelines. The judge cited the retired self-employed antiques dealer's health when issuing the sentence.
Gordon, who
claimed to have bought the ornate desk from the descendant of a Connecticut
soldier, pleaded guilty in January 2019 to one count of wire fraud.
“Harold
Gordon has caused me severe embarrassment, loss of my nationally recognized
reputation as a foremost expert and an unmeasurable loss in business,” folk art
expert and “Antiques Roadshow” appraiser Allan Katz said in a court document.
Gordon, 71, a master woodworker, admitted to converting a
secretary desk at his Templeton, Mass., home into an extravagant fake.
According to
the government, Gordon, by “engaging in mendacity at every turn,” told Katz
that the circa 1876 desk was made for the family of a Connecticut soldier, John
Bingham, who died at the Battle of Antietam in 1862. Gordon’s calculated
efforts included providing false provenance for the piece of furniture,
authorities said.
“He further
falsely stated that the surviving members of the soldier’s regiment, including
Wells Bingham (John’s brother), had decorated the secretary desk to give as a
war memorial to the fallen soldier’s family,” prosecutors said in a
presentencing memo.
Desk in Hartford in 2017 (Courtesy of John Banks' Civil War blog) |
While the Bingham boys did fight with the 16th Connecticut Infantry, the story about the desk wasn’t true. Gordon’s exacting work on the desk was convincing, down to the Civil War-era tools and materials he used in the scheme.
Standing
8-feet tall, the desk, made of walnut, oak and maple, has drawers, a bookcase
and intricate artisanal touches. The handcrafted the words “Antietam” and “Sept.
17, 1862” were made from barnyard bone and Gordon fashioned a cloth star out of
period fabric to make it resemble a remnant of the 16th
Connecticut’s battle flag, prosecutor asserted. A clock at the top includes the
words “The Union Preserved.”
Gordon sold
the desk to Katz – who had studied the desk for its authenticity – in March 2014
for $64,500. Katz made a video detailing the desk and it was put up for sale
for $375,000, according to news reports, at the Winter Antiques Show in New
York. The Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art in Hartford, Conn., purchased the
desk for an undisclosed price in early 2015. Katz later paid another $25,000 to
Gordon because of the tidy profit from that sale, prosecutors said.
(Courtesy of John Banks’ Civil War blog) |
At the time, the museum said it was “thrilled to add this stunning piece” to its collection of folk art and Civil War-era items.
Civil War
blogger John Banks, who has followed the story of the desk for several years,
detailed what’s known about the Bingham brothers in a 2011 post. The East
Haddam residents were just teenagers when they joined the Union army. John, 17,
son of a farmer, died in the fighting at a cornfield at Antietam. Wells
survived the war
The story of
the amazing artifact unraveled in 2018, according to reports, when the editor
of the Maine Antique Report noticed the Bingham desk appeared to be similar to
an unadorned desk photographed at Gordon’s home. The woodworker then admitted
the desk’s story was bogus.
Gordon was
boastful about the fraudulent piece and said that he “had created a new art
form,” the government contended. “It’s
the apotheosis of my own making,” Gordon said in an interview, according to a
March 2018 New York Times article.
Detail of Abraham Lincoln (John Banks) |
Gordon apologized Tuesday via video conference, according to the Hartford Courant.
His lawyers argued that when
he first began work on the fake, he had no intention of selling it. He worked
from a desk that indeed dated to the Civil War period, they stated.
“He put the
piece in his living room and intended to keep it. But when his medical
conditions intensified in 2012, impeding his ability to work, and his medical
expenses mounted, he grew desperate,” they argued in documents.
Katz, in his written statement, said Gordon “has caused me severe embarrassment, loss of my nationally recognized reputation as a foremost expert and an unmeasurable loss in business.” He said the master craftsman spent two years working to deceive him and basked in the attention he gave in interviews about his fraudulent handiwork.
Gordon’s
lawyers have said their client was not motivated by money or prestige.
Katz made
full restitution to the Hartford museum, which said forgers like Gordon do
great damage to the cultural marketplace. “The opportunism of this forgery was
both craven and bald in its intent to maximize financial gain and to ensnare a
number of institutions and organizations in the process,” the CEO for the Wadsworth
Atheneum said.
The unidentified curator involved in the transaction no longer works for the
museum.
“Mr. Gordon has deeply impaired my credibility as a scholar and curator. As a result of Mr. Gordon’s crimes, my achievements and relationship with the Wadsworth Atheneum have been completely incinerated. I will never be able to return to this institution that once valued my service and applauded my efforts as a curator,” she wrote.
The Picket reached out Thursday to Gordon’s federal public defender but did not hear back. His lawyers wrote that Gordon had no previous criminal history and he hopes to make restitution to Katz.U.S. District Judge Jeffrey A. Meyer ordered Gordon to also pay $84,500 in restitution to Katz, who retained the item. The latter said in a 2019 interview that he and his wife “plan on donating it to an institution that might be receptive to having it.”
According to the Courant, Meyer said he would have sent Gordon to prison if it were not for his health problems, which include cardiovascular and Parkinson’s disease.
No comments:
Post a Comment